Questions tagged [discussion]

The question you're asking is designed to solicit opinions or best-practices on a particular topic, with the goal of reaching community consensus.

Filter by
Sorted by
Tagged with
4
votes
2answers
115 views

Why did my question get so many down votes

I asked this question with genuine interest, supplied sufficient information about it, and showed that I have done prior research, but it still got downvoted a lot which is shocking to me. I was eager ...
8
votes
2answers
99 views

Copyrighted codes/standards and fair use

Frequently it is useful to reference codes and standards in either questions or answers. However, many (if not most) codes are copyrighted and should be purchased from the responsible entities. How ...
2
votes
1answer
36 views

Can questions asking for the distinction between two engineering phenomenon be on-topic?

I'm new here, so I thought I would double check. I've just asked the question How to explain why the statement “Cavitation is boiling,” in an answer is not really correct. Obviously the question does ...
1
vote
1answer
36 views

Why is there no close flag option for recommendation questions?

Regarding questions for resource recommendation, Meta says "No!". So why is there not flag option for it, like on other sites? On StackOverflow it looks like this: Questions asking us to recommend ...
5
votes
2answers
96 views

How do we handle questions about conspiracies that contain engineering topics?

I took a quick look around and I couldn't find previous discussion, so I thought I would bring this up. I was inspired by this question, which asks about whether jet fuel can melt steel beams (yes, ...
0
votes
3answers
126 views

So many on-hold questions

As I write this post, 12 of the 30 questions on the first two pages of "Questions" are [on hold]. I'm a newbie here, but that seems high. As I understand it from reading other meta posts, this site ...
1
vote
1answer
40 views

Information needed about a closed question

So I asked This Question earlier and am still having hard time understanding how I am supposed to ask this in a more intuitive way, so the boards will accept my question in general. I have went back ...
0
votes
0answers
21 views

Are questions inquiring about the existance of particular inventions\tools in scope here\elsewhere? [duplicate]

I was particularly looking to ask a question about whether devices\methods have been developed to aid urban core fire departments to speed the sluggish, grueling ascent in skyscrapers when existing ...
3
votes
1answer
28 views

Increasing Answer Feedback

I've noticed several questions with only one answer and no feedback (requester not accepting the answer and no upvotes) which seems to still leave the question unresolved since users have no idea if ...
9
votes
1answer
115 views

Do you want me as a non-mechanical engineer to ask questions about mechanical drawing symbols?

As an electronics hobbyist and student, I often find myself in a situation where I have to interpret mechanical drawings, such as those describing the physical properties of connectors and ...
0
votes
1answer
82 views

Why close questions just because they are difficult?

I recently had this question closed with the motivation that it was too broad: https://engineering.stackexchange.com/questions/10378/intuitive-understanding-of-constitutive-laws-for-beam-properties ...
2
votes
2answers
38 views

When did the tags “rail” and “railroad” get merged?

I see that railroad is a synonym of rail. When did this happen and why? It seems that at the very least, this is the wrong way, i.e. rail->railroad should be the direction. In the railroad industry ...
2
votes
2answers
41 views

How should we handle questions that specifically state that they are cross-posted?

Lately we have had some questions that specifically state that they are asked on other StackExchange sites: What is the etymology of "bridge cam gauge"? Looking for a common term for "...
12
votes
2answers
138 views

How to use the Engineering Stack Exchange site as a classroom activity?

I am a professor of Chemical Engineering, teaching topics ranging from mass and energy balance, to thermodynamics, to transport phenomena. I have been thinking of ways in which to incorporate ...
2
votes
0answers
41 views

Should bare questions like this be closed? [closed]

With some questions such as this one it is difficult to know if there is enough context to answer the question - if there is any chance of someone with specialist experience being able to answer it. ...
3
votes
1answer
38 views

Can I ask a question here that I already asked on another Stack Exchange site?

I have asked this question on Aviation SE, which I think would also interest the community here on Engineering SE. Up to this point I haven't received complete answers to my question on Aviation. May ...
6
votes
3answers
55 views

Should applicable questions be tagged with the requisite code?

I'm a civil engineer and I mostly stay on that side of this site. I am also a Brazilian living in Brazil, which has its own structural codes, distinct from those in Europe and the US. Given how much ...
10
votes
3answers
141 views

Is it appropriate to answer the question we think the poster is asking in low quality posts?

If someone asks a poorly defined question but their intent or interest can be inferred is it appropriate to answer the question that you think they are asking ? This may be particularly relevant ...
2
votes
1answer
64 views

Should we change the title of “Identify this” questions once the answer is known?

Sometimes our site gets questions where the asker doesn't know what something is and provides a picture. As a site, we have come to the understanding that these types of questions are acceptable as ...
4
votes
2answers
51 views

When is urban planning on-topic on engineering?

There exists an Urban Planning proposal on Area51. Many proposed questions are about traffic planning. For example: Do pedestrian crossings with countdown signals reduce the number of fatalities ...
1
vote
1answer
53 views

Are CAD software usage related questions on topic here? [duplicate]

Say, I want to know how to convert 3D Polylines into 2D polylines in draftsight, or the questions that are covered in area 51 proposal here. My questions have to do with how to use CAD system to ...
0
votes
1answer
23 views

Is there an earthquake tag, or can we make one? [duplicate]

I was looking for an earthquake tag for my new question but didn't find one. Can we make one?
1
vote
1answer
33 views

How can I create a new tag?

I want to create a new tag for trains for my question here. How can I do this? Does an admin have to do it for me?
4
votes
4answers
210 views

Do we want a general disclaimer

Wait, what?! Haven't we already discussed the subject of a general disclaimer on the site? Why yes, yes we have. And in that discussion, the consensus was that "No, we don't." But that conclusion ...
10
votes
3answers
525 views

Proposal: Add a custom close reason for homework questions that don't show effort

Update 2016/09/08: Based on the answer provided by Air (it's long, read toward the middle) and more recent usage on the site, Homework-type questions have been closed with the Unclear What You Are ...
2
votes
0answers
41 views

Is there a policy for questions/discussions which lead to a new discovery?

I believe that a forum like this provides one with the possibility of sourcing a wide spectrum of engineering know-how thus it could be a useful and efficient medium for developing projects or ...
1
vote
0answers
39 views

Are AutoCAD usage questions on topic here? [duplicate]

Are AutoCAD usage questions on topic here? The CAD proposal didn't pick up steam and was closed.
7
votes
3answers
190 views

Why are questions regarding discussions or product sourcing not allowed on engineering stackexchange?

I have answered many questions here on engineering stack exchange, but I find it impossible for myself to ask an engineering question. Any question that I can frame to meet the rules, I could more ...
10
votes
2answers
158 views

How should we handle home modification questions?

We have received some questions about home modifications. The answer typically boils down to "It is probably more complicated that you imagine. Hire an engineer." Each question is similar, but unique....
1
vote
3answers
48 views

Question closed for bad project?

I'm curious as to why this question was closed. So far as i can see from reading the reasons a post can be closed, there is no validity for shutting someone down for having their project be bad. His ...
0
votes
1answer
37 views

Can I ask this question: Is there any aspect of a nuclear weapon test that cannot be simulated using super computers?

Nuclear weapons tests are experiments carried out to determine the effectiveness, yield, and explosive capability of nuclear weapons. However, these days most nuclear weapon states uses Super ...
5
votes
2answers
53 views

On-topicness of material recommendations

Possibly related: The Engineering.SE position on recommendation/finding stuff questions How to write material design questions I have a specific piece of equipment in need of a casing. This casing ...
6
votes
2answers
126 views

Are too many questions tagged with “mechanical-engineering”?

At the beginning of our site (not even a year ago), there was an effort to tag every question with one of the "big three" engineering disciplines (electrical, mechanical, and civil). See: Don't forget ...
8
votes
2answers
101 views

More upvotes required to offset questions without accepted answers?

I am newer to the Stack Exchange and the Engineering SE so forgive any naivete. With fewer users on this site in particular, it seems more important that up votes are cast to reward and filter good ...
6
votes
1answer
36 views

The unfiltered [filter] tag

I noticed today that we've got at least two distinct classes of question using the filters tag: Mechanical filtration questions, e.g. Gas cleaning in activated carbon filters - How much moisture is ...
3
votes
3answers
58 views

Tag clarification: building-physics

I just saw the tag "building-physics" on a question about tire-balancing beads. Which seemed strange to me, as car tires have nothing to do with buildings. On checking the tag wiki... there's nothing....
6
votes
3answers
92 views

Answering questions with comments

I often answer easy questions with just a comment, for many of the same reasons mentioned in this thread. On another StackExchange site which I'm active on, this practice is fairly common, especially ...
2
votes
1answer
43 views

Why has this question had so many more views than average?

This question has had over 1600 views in 2 days. Which is orders of magnitude more than the average views for questions on the Engineering StackExchange site. From a quick scroll through recent ...
2
votes
2answers
60 views

Topicality of questions about differing versions of books

A recent question asks about the difference between two versions of what many would consider a canonical textbook for multiple fields. There is modest community consensus that questions regarding ...
6
votes
2answers
118 views

Naive questions

I read https://engineering.stackexchange.com/help/on-topic which says questions will be well received when they (among other things) Excite or challenge experienced professionals in the field ...
1
vote
2answers
49 views

Do we need a generic live load / dead load question, in order to create a canonical answer?

I saw this question today, on whether hydrostatic loads are "dead" or live". Very heavily related is this previous question on whether a moving load (that is always somewhere) is "dead" or "live". I ...
1
vote
1answer
67 views

What is yet needed to leave the beta status?

Checking periodically the Area51 page of the site, I am very happy that most stat are at least in "okay" status. Although the question/day stat is still seems to oscillate around the required minimum (...
1
vote
1answer
33 views

Why was my comment deleted?

I'm pretty sure I left a comment to: How was Volkswagen able to trick the lab pollution test? Yet now it isn't there. Why was it deleted? And why I cannot find ANY trace of my prose anywhere in the ...
5
votes
2answers
71 views

Is my question on safety practices for WWTP plant visits salvageble?

This question of mine was closed as to broad. Reasons given where that a good answer would be beyond the scope of SE. Since then there's also a request for reopening, not by me (reopen-voter, speak up!...
7
votes
0answers
116 views

Embedded.SE shutting down

Embedded.StackExchange is no longer. The official reason is listed here at their Area51 page: The Embedded Systems site didn't have enough activity during the beta and has been closed. And while ...
0
votes
1answer
39 views

Would this reworking of my rejected migrated question be acceptable for the Main.SE?

Rejected Migrated Question Here Reworking here:
5
votes
1answer
45 views

Are questions regarding drafting on topic here?

Just found this Engineering stack-exchange site. From browsing the help and meta, it seems this is pretty new. I would imagine some, or most, of the users here are familiar with Eng-Tips as well - ...
5
votes
1answer
34 views

Is a question about how to mill metals in a specific situation on topic?

I need to better understand metal milling, specifically speeds and feeds, and don't know where to start. I have a specific project where I need to machine 5/8" diameter slots into an aluminum block ...
5
votes
5answers
335 views

The Engineering.SE policy on check-my-work questions

We have recently received a few check-my-work questions: Heat Loss per Linear Ft Problem with Energy Transfer Rate Conversion https://engineering.stackexchange.com/questions/3687/standard-thickness-...
2
votes
3answers
48 views

Clean up solar tags

I noticed a recent question (How can I connect mismatched solar panels in parallel?) with three tags relating to solar power/photovoltaics. Each of these is an existing tag: solar-panel has 6 ...